Anyone regret not adding an extra return during a DIY build?

I’m in the planning stage for a DIY pool and trying to lock things in before plumbing gets buried. Right now I’ve got two returns planned but I keep wondering if I should add a third while it’s easy. Anyone wish they had added more circulation points during their build?
 
I’m in the planning stage for a DIY pool and trying to lock things in before plumbing gets buried. Right now I’ve got two returns planned but I keep wondering if I should add a third while it’s easy. Anyone wish they had added more circulation points during their build?
I only put in two and definitely wish I’d added a third. One area of the pool is harder to keep clean and fixing it later would mean cutting concrete. If you’re already there, I’d overdo it a bit.
 
I’m in the planning stage for a DIY pool and trying to lock things in before plumbing gets buried. Right now I’ve got two returns planned but I keep wondering if I should add a third while it’s easy. Anyone wish they had added more circulation points during their build?
I added an extra return and capped it at first. Ended up using it a year later when I changed my circulation setup. Cost me almost nothing upfront and gave me options later
 
I’m in the planning stage for a DIY pool and trying to lock things in before plumbing gets buried. Right now I’ve got two returns planned but I keep wondering if I should add a third while it’s easy. Anyone wish they had added more circulation points during their build?
Depends on pool size and shape. Mine is pretty basic and two returns work fine. But if you’ve got benches, tanning ledges or weird angles, more returns help prevent dead spots.
 
That’s exactly what I was worried about. Sounds like adding one now is cheap insurance, even if I don’t use it right away. Appreciate the input.
 
I only put in two and definitely wish I’d added a third. One area of the pool is harder to keep clean and fixing it later would mean cutting concrete. If you’re already there, I’d overdo it a bit.
I get what John Knight was saying about hard-to-clean areas. From my experience, adding one more return now feels like cheap insurance, you might not need it right away, but you’ll appreciate it when the water moves better and dead spots don’t show up.
 
I added an extra return and capped it at first. Ended up using it a year later when I changed my circulation setup. Cost me almost nothing upfront and gave me options later
From what Warren Dale mentioned about adding an extra return and capping it, I went that route during my build too. When plumbing is still open, the cost of adding one more line is minor compared to cutting concrete later to fix a dead spot. In my pool with a tanning ledge, the extra return helped circulation stay more even and kept pH more stable by preventing stagnant areas. For me it’s less about using it immediately and more about long-term flexibility before everything gets permanently sealed up.
 
If you’re even thinking about it now, that usually tells you something.

I didn’t add a third during my build because I thought two would be fine for a “simple rectangle.” What I didn’t fully account for was how benches and step areas mess with flow. Once everything was up and running, I had one stubborn corner where fine debris would just hang out. Not dramatic, just annoying enough that I noticed it every week.

I managed it by tweaking eyeballs and slightly increasing run time, but it also meant after heavier bather load days that area clouded up first and my filter pressure would climb a few psi faster than expected. Nothing catastrophic, just not as balanced as it could’ve been.

If plumbing is still open, adding a third and valving it so you can control or even cap it is cheap flexibility. You don’t have to blast it full time. Sometimes just having the option to redirect flow seasonally makes a difference, especially if wind consistently pushes surface debris one direction.

Once concrete is poured, you’re basically married to the layout. Extra return now is a small line item. Retrofitting later is a jackhammer. If your pool has any ledges, benches, or odd angles, I’d personally overbuild circulation and dial it back rather than wish you had more movement later.
 
Back
Top