Yeah, I’ve had that exact head-scratcher and it’s annoying because on paper everything looks fine. Filters clean, sanitizer reading okay, shock done, but the water still has that dull, hazy look that won’t quite clear. Makes you start second-guessing everything.
What was happening in my tub was a mix of fine particles plus chemistry that was just barely off. My alkalinity had slipped low without me noticing, so even though chlorine was present, it wasn’t really doing its job efficiently. That alone can keep tiny stuff suspended instead of letting it filter out. On top of that, oils from a couple short soaks were hanging around and the filter pressure was creeping up faster than usual, which told me the filter was catching junk but not fast enough to clear the water.
What finally worked was fixing the alkalinity floor first so the pH stopped drifting, then using a small dose of water clarifier from aquadoc. Not a dump-and-pray amount, just enough to help the fine particles clump so the filter could actually grab them. I let the circulation run longer than normal and stayed out of the tub for a day. By the next evening the water went from cloudy to that clear, glassy look again. If it comes back quickly after that, then yeah, line buildup might be the next thing to look at, but for me it never got that far.
Cloudy water with “normal” test results is usually the tub telling you something’s slightly out of balance, not that everything’s broken. Anyone else notice their water looks clear again right after fixing alkalinity, even before adding anything else?