If the water is getting dirty but the pressure needle never budges, that usually means the filter isn’t actually being asked to do much work, even though it looks like it should be. One thing I don’t see mentioned yet is bypassing inside the filter.
If the multiport valve or the standpipe seal is leaking internally, water can sneak past the sand instead of being forced through it. When that happens, debris stays in the pool, flow looks kind of okay, and pressure stays flat because there’s no real resistance building up. I chased this for a while thinking my gauge was dead, but the giveaway was that backwashing didn’t really change anything and the water quality never improved much either.
Another clue is the type of dirt you’re seeing. If it’s fine dust or haze that never seems to collect on the floor or improve after vacuuming, that often points to channeling or hardened sand. The filter just isn’t trapping it anymore, so pressure never rises like you’d expect.
If it were mine, I’d pop the gauge off and flush the port like John said, then backwash and rinse as usual. If pressure still sits at the same number with visibly dirty water, I’d be looking inside the filter next. A sand bed that’s gone solid or a valve letting water shortcut the media will act exactly like this. Anyone else notice the pool looks dirty but the returns feel just as strong as ever?