The biggest thing I learned after a couple seasons is that there isn’t one “correct” checklist, it’s more about protecting the parts that can crack and not trapping problems under the cover.
My routine now is pretty simple. I pick a stretch of dry weather, give the pool a really thorough clean (walls, steps, waterline), and make sure the chemistry is calm, not aggressive. I don’t like closing right after a heavy shock because I’ve found it can be rough on liners and fittings when it sits sealed for months. I’ll let it circulate overnight so everything evens out.
For water level, I aim for moderate, not extreme. Just enough room so ice or meltwater isn’t pressing directly into the skimmer, but not so low that the cover is unsupported. Then I focus most of my effort on the plumbing, making sure lines are empty, sealed, and the equipment is fully drained. That’s where real winter damage usually comes from, not the exact inch the water sits at.
One thing I do differently now than my first year is slowing down. I spread it over two days instead of rushing it all at once. When I tried to do everything in one afternoon, I always missed something small. Since I started taking my time, spring openings have been way less dramatic.