I used to wonder the same thing because daily testing sounded obsessive and weekly felt a little too relaxed. What I figured out is neither of you is really “wrong,” it just depends on how hard the tub is working. Hot tubs are tiny systems, so heat plus aeration plus bather load can swing things way faster than people expect.
For me, once a week only works if the tub barely gets used. Any time we’re soaking a few times a week, I’ll at least do a quick check every couple days. Not a full chemistry session, just enough to see if sanitizer is getting chewed up or if pH drift has started. I learned the hard way that by the time the water looks or smells off, alkalinity has usually already slid and I’m playing catch-up. Keeping that alkalinity floor steady was the biggest stabilizer, once that’s locked in, pH doesn’t bounce nearly as much.
My routine now is light checks every 2 to 3 days, then a proper test once a week. If we have people over or the jets run a lot, I’ll check the next day without waiting. I’ll use quick reads midweek, sometimes with a digital tester like the aquadoc eagle ray, then confirm with the drop kit on the weekend. It’s way less work than draining cloudy water later. Weekly testing isn’t wrong, it just assumes nothing changes in between, and hot tubs rarely behave that politely. Anyone else notice chemistry goes sideways faster after one heavy soak than after three quiet days?