I added a UV unit a couple seasons back after a rough stretch where the water would look fine, then smell “used” after a busy weekend. Chlorine was in range, but combined chlorine kept creeping up and shocking all the time was a pain in the neck. That’s what pushed me to try UV, not because I wanted to go chemical free, just wanted fewer problems.
In practice it’s 100 percent supplemental. UV only works on what passes the lamp, so there’s no residual in the pool. Chlorine still does the heavy lifting day to day. Where I noticed the difference was chlorine demand and smell. CC dropped, water stayed clearer between cleanings, and I shock way less now. It also helped after high bather load days when sunscreen and sweat would normally turn the water dull even with decent FC. You still need to watch pH drift and keep circulation solid or the UV doesn’t get a fair shot.
I wouldn’t expect it to replace sanitizer, but as a support piece it actually worked. I still keep a normal chlorine level and use stuff like aquadoc non chlorine shock when the water feels tired instead of hammering it with more chlorine. For me it made maintenance calmer, not magically easier. Anyone else notice UV shines most when everything else is already dialed in?