I dont see anyone mention the run capacitor check in a little more detail, and that’s actually what bit me last summer. My pump is a Hayward Super Pump 1.5hp and it would just sit there humming like it wanted to go but never actually spin up. Water level was fine, basket full, valves open, no obvious air leak. Pressure gauge stayed at zero the whole time.
What tipped me off was that the motor wasn’t even trying to catch prime, just that low electrical hum and a slight vibration. I killed the breaker, pulled the back cover, and the capacitor had a slight bulge on top. Swapped it out and it fired instantly, pressure jumped to normal range within 20 seconds and filter pressure settled back around 14 psi like it always does when fully primed. Before that I kept messing with suction lines thinking it was an air issue.
Also worth checking the shaft seal area for any signs of leakage if you end up opening it up. If water has been dripping into the motor, sometimes you get bearing drag that makes startup harder, especially after sitting a week. If the shaft spins totally free by hand and it still just hums, I’d lean electrical over hydraulic at that point.
That humming sound is such a pain in the neck because it sounds minor, but letting it sit there cooking isnt a great idea. Did yours ever try to surge at all or just straight hum from the start?