Pool and Spa Equipment Reviews

Nathaniel Perez

Nathaniel Perez

Member
Could you share in detail your experience with pool and spa equipment (such as pumps, filters, heaters, or automatic cleaners), including the brand and model you use, their pros and cons, durability, and whether or not you would recommend them?
 
Great question! I’ve been using a robotic pool cleaner for a while, and I must say, it’s a game-changer. It’s saved me so much time, but it’s also a little loud at times. Anyone else tried robotic cleaners? Would love to hear if they’ve worked well for you!
 
I’ve had good luck with my Hayward variable-speed pump (TriStar VS). It’s been running for about three seasons now, and the energy savings are noticeable compared to the old single-speed unit. The main plus is how quiet it is; you barely hear it once it’s on a lower setting.

The downside is the upfront cost, which initially felt steep, but it’s already paying for itself on the power bill. If you’re planning a long-term setup, I’d definitely recommend going with variable speed.
 
Benjamin Lewis said:
Great question! I’ve been using a robotic pool cleaner for a while, and I must say, it’s a game-changer. It’s saved me so much time, but it’s also a little loud at times. Anyone else tried robotic cleaners? Would love to hear if they’ve worked well for you!
Click to expand...
Thanks for sharing! I’ll definitely look into robotic cleaners. Sounds like a great time-saver, even if they’re a bit loud at times.
 
Katherine Morgan said:
I’ve had good luck with my Hayward variable-speed pump (TriStar VS). It’s been running for about three seasons now, and the energy savings are noticeable compared to the old single-speed unit. The main plus is how quiet it is; you barely hear it once it’s on a lower setting.

The downside is the upfront cost, which initially felt steep, but it’s already paying for itself on the power bill. If you’re planning a long-term setup, I’d definitely recommend going with variable speed.
Click to expand...
Thanks for the recommendation! I’ll consider a variable-speed pump for long-term savings. Sounds like a smart investment.
 
I’ve been running a Pentair cartridge filter for a couple of years now, and it’s been solid. Super easy to clean compared to the sand filter I had before, and the water stays really clear. The only downside is when it does need a rinse, you’ve got to take it apart, which is a bit of a hassle compared to just backwashing. That said, it uses less water overall and feels like less maintenance in the long run. I’d recommend it if you don’t mind doing the occasional deeper clean.
 
I’ve been using a Raypak gas heater on my pool for about four years now, and it’s been very dependable. The thing I love most is how quickly it warms the water, even on chilly mornings, and the digital controls make it simple to set the exact temperature you want. Build quality seems strong, and I haven’t had any major problems.

The only drawbacks are that it makes some noise when it kicks in and the installation cost was a bit higher than I expected. In terms of maintenance, I just give the burner a clean and check for debris once a year, which is straightforward enough.

Would I recommend it? Definitely. If you want fast, reliable heating and don’t mind a little startup noise, this heater is a solid investment that makes swimming much more enjoyable.
 
I’ve been running a Jandy VS FloPro variable-speed pump paired with a Jandy cartridge filter for about two seasons now, and I’ve been pretty happy with the setup. The pump is quiet and has a nice range of speeds, so I can run it longer at a lower setting without racking up the power bill. The filter keeps the water crystal clear, and I only need to open it up for a rinse a few times a season.

The one drawback is the cost of replacement cartridges, they’re not cheap, but they last a while if you take care of them. Overall, I’d recommend the combo if you’re after energy efficiency and clear water with minimal fuss.
 
I’ve got a mix of equipment, so here’s my take from a few seasons of use. For pumps, I went with a Pentair IntelliFlo variable-speed unit, and it’s been a huge difference compared to my old single-speed pump. It’s whisper-quiet on low settings and has shaved a noticeable chunk off my electricity bill. The only downside is the price upfront, but for long-term savings and flexibility, I think it’s worth it.

For filtration, I use a Hayward cartridge filter. Super easy to clean, keeps the water really clear, and I like that it uses less water than a sand filter. The minor downside is having to disassemble it for a full clean occasionally, but it’s not a big deal if you stay on top of maintenance.

On the heating side, I went with a Raypak gas heater. It warms the water fast, even on cold mornings, and the digital controls make it simple to hit the exact temperature I want. It’s a little noisy when it fires up, but reliability and speed outweigh that.

If I had to recommend, I’d say prioritize variable-speed pumps and good filtration first, then add heating or robots depending on your budget and convenience needs.
 
I’ve been using a Dolphin Explorer E70 cleaner and a Pentair SuperFlo VS pump for a little over two years, and both have held up great so far. The cleaner is a bit on the pricey side, but it’s saved me a ton of manual work. It climbs the walls well, gets into corners better than most, and the filter basket is super easy to rinse out. The only small complaint is that it sometimes hesitates on my pool steps, but nothing major.

As for the pump, the SuperFlo has been a solid performer. It’s quiet even when running at higher speeds, and the adjustable settings really help with energy use, I’ve noticed a drop in my power bill since swapping out the old single-speed one.

If I had to nitpick, the Dolphin’s power supply cable feels a little delicate, so I try not to move it around too much. Other than that, both pieces of equipment have been reliable and low-maintenance. I’d recommend the combo to anyone who wants efficient performance without having to constantly tinker with the system.
 
Here’s my breakdown from a few seasons managing my pool and spa setup:

Pump: I run a Pentair IntelliFlo variable-speed pump. Absolutely love it, super quiet on low settings, energy-efficient, and gives you the flexibility to run it at different speeds depending on the task. The only drawback is the upfront cost, but it’s paid off in electricity savings over a couple of seasons.

Filter: Hayward cartridge filter. Easy to maintain, keeps water crystal clear, and uses far less water than a sand filter. The only minor inconvenience is having to disassemble it for a deep clean occasionally, but it’s straightforward if you stay on top of it.

Heater: Raypak gas heater. Fast, reliable heating, even on chilly mornings. Digital controls make it easy to hit the exact temp, though it’s a bit noisy when it fires up. Installation cost was higher than I expected, but the performance is worth it.

Robotic Cleaner: Dolphin Explorer E70. Expensive initially, but it’s saved me tons of manual work. Climbing walls and corners is great, filter baskets are easy to rinse, and maintenance is minimal. The only caveat is the power cable feels delicate, so I handle it carefully.

Overall: I’d prioritize a variable-speed pump and solid filtration first. Heating or robotic cleaners come next depending on budget and convenience. All these units have been durable and reliable over a couple of years. Highly recommend this combo if you want efficiency and low-maintenance performance.
 
This thread is making me realize how similar a lot of setups end up once you live with them for a few seasons. I’ll share mine, not because it’s perfect, but because I learned where the real wins and annoyances are.

Pump wise, I’m running a Pentair SuperFlo VS on a mid sized pool. The problem before was noise and power draw, my old single speed sounded like a shop vac and the electric bill always spiked in summer. Switching to variable speed fixed both. I run it low and long instead of short and hard, filter pressure stays steady, and turnover is way smoother. Only con is the programming takes a little patience at first. Once it’s set, you forget about it.

Filter is a cartridge setup, Hayward model, and I wouldn’t go back to sand. The water stays clearer, especially after heavy bather load weekends, and I’m not wasting water backwashing all the time. Downside is when pressure creeps up 8 to 10 psi, you’re pulling it apart and hosing it down. I soak mine a couple times a year and that’s made a big difference.

Heater is where opinions get strong. I’ve got a gas unit and yeah, it’s not quiet and it’s not cheap to run. But the problem it solves is consistency. One cold night used to drop the water temp enough that nobody wanted to swim. Now it’s stable. Keeping calcium and alkalinity in range matters here, once I let that slide and saw scale starting, so I stay on top of saturation index now.

On the maintenance side, good equipment only works if the water is actually clean. I’ve found staying ahead of grime matters more than brand names. I use aquadoc products for surface and waterline cleaning, mostly because they don’t mess with balance, and that keeps equipment from working harder than it should. Less gunk going into the filter means pressure rises slower and the whole system runs calmer.

Would I recommend my setup? Yeah, but with a caveat. Variable speed pump and cartridge filter are must haves in my book. Heater depends on climate and how often you actually swim. Robots are great if you hate brushing. Biggest lesson for me is equipment matters, but water balance and realistic run settings matter more. Curious if anyone else noticed their gear behaves totally different once chemistry is dialed in instead of just “acceptable”.
 
A salt system usually feels like less work because FC stays steadier so you are not constantly dosing chlorine by hand, but you trade that for more pH drift upward (cell aeration) and possible scale on the cell, so I still test FC and pH 2 to 3x a week, keep CYA around 60 to 80 ppm for SWG so the sun does not burn off chlorine fast, and if you start seeing white crust on the cell or walls, AquaDoc Pool Stain and Scale Control helps keep scaling from turning into a headache.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top