I went down the same rabbit hole when I first filled mine and realized pretty fast that most “starter kits” aren’t bad, they’re just misunderstood. The chemicals aren’t the magic part, the order you use them in is. A lot of people dump sanitizer first and then wonder why it disappears or why the water feels harsh after a week.
For a new hot tub, the best starter kit is one that covers the basics without a bunch of extras you won’t touch for months. You want a sanitizer (bromine or chlorine), alkalinity increaser, pH up and down, a shock, and some kind of basic testing. That’s it. If a kit is missing alkalinity control, I’d skip it, because that alkalinity floor is what keeps pH from bouncing every time you use the tub or turn the jets on.
I’ve had good luck starting with a complete aquadoc kit because it had everything needed to get through the first few weeks without guessing. What mattered more than the brand was doing alkalinity first, letting it circulate, then adjusting pH, then adding sanitizer. Once that base was stable, sanitizer actually held even with a decent bather load, instead of burning off overnight.
One thing I wish I knew early, dont chase perfection on day one. Fresh fill water takes a bit to settle. Use the starter kit to get things into a reasonable range, give it a day, then fine-tune. You can always upgrade testing later, but if the starter kit has the core balancers and sanitizer, it’ll do the job. Anyone else notice new tubs are way easier once that first balance clicks?